I've Tested ! DNA and Genealogy
   
DNA Results and Ethnic Heritage  DNA Testing and Accuracy
   
Statistics Testing for Jewish Ancestry
   
DNA Tests and Planning  




I've Tested !

Have you already received your DNA genealogy test results and need help understanding them? We can help. For the first time ever, using the information available through genealogy DNA testing, people are beginning to truly be able to answer the age-old question “where did I come from” on a scope and scale unimaginable even a few years ago.

If this describes you and what you need, congratulations, you are a genetic genealogy pioneer. DNA for genealogy, called genetic genealogy, is an infant science (the first genetic genealogy test was performed in 2000), and you are one of the first wave of people in the world to utilize these new tools. Discoveries are made daily, and this new language and landscape can be very overwhelming and confusing for newcomers.

When I began this journey, I felt like I was drinking from a fire hose. Six years and lots of education later, I’m very excited about the breakthrough’s we’ve made and what we can now discern from genealogy DNA testing. As a surname administrator for many projects, I needed to make DNA test results interesting and understandable for everyone. Now this service is available for you too.

We offer several products and services designed to do just that, interpret your DNA results, in plain English, explaining scientific terms and what they mean to you and your family, presented so that even your Grandmother can understand and enjoy. In fact, we’re Grandmother tested and approved!!!


Testimonial from a Grandmother      Testimonial from a Satisfied Client 


DNA and Genealogy - Yield a Variety of Information !

DNA tests for genealogy can provide you with many kinds of information:

Genealogical
Genetic genealogy connects you with members of your family who have lived since the time that surnames were adopted which varied depending on where your ancestors lived. Often, traditional genealogical records confirm DNA evidence. Sometimes DNA evidence bridges the gap where traditional genealogical records no longer exist.

The timeframe covered by genetic genealogy is typically less than 500 years, but can extend to 1000 or so if you are lucky enough to connect to a royal house or other firmly established genealogy.

For more information,  the Family Tree DNA website:

www.familytreedna.com



Anthro-Genealogy
This is the fuzzy gray area where some last names or traditional family clan names existed, but you can’t connect directly to them using traditional genealogical evidence. Your DNA may or may not match with similar last names, or your DNA may point to a geographical area where similar last names existed, but known descendants aren’t available to test. Just the same, geographical, historical and DNA results combined can provide important information as to where your ancestors lived before the age of traditional genealogical records. This timeframe often reaches back 500 – 2000 years.

Anthropological also known as Deep Ancestry
Your haplogroup is determined during DNA testing. Your haplogroup is your deep ancestral clan. DNA testing is the only way to discover your Deep Ancestral Clan, because it reaches back before last names existed, in fact, tens of thousands of years ago.

DNA results can clearly indicate your DNA clan. Population genetics and many studies, some recently published and many still underway continue to expand our understanding of where your ancestral clan lived and moved. This timeframe extends back in time from the beginning of last names to the beginnings of the human race. Using the knowledge we are gaining of mutations, when and where in the world they occurred, we can trace your ancestors back in time, thousands of years, and show the paths they took to reach the areas where we find them in the Anthro-Genealogical and Genealogical timeframes.

You may think that little information is available about these ancestors, but that isn’t true. We’ve written a series of books, the HaploClan series, one for each Haplogroup, or Deep Ancestral Clan. These HaploClan “Meet Your Ancestors” books are about 100 pages each and are full of information about how and where your ancestors lived, the environment surrounding them, archaeological remains, their cultures and spiritual practices along with photos and maps.

Using all three types of information provided by genealogy DNA testing, people are beginning to truly be able understand our ancestry, not just in last few hundred years, but in the thousands and tens of thousands of years in the past.

Where were your ancestors 10,000 years ago? Where did they overwinter the last ice age? What did they ear? Did they worship? Did they create art? Your DNA holds the secrets, and now we can unravel your personal mystery.

Click here to see what you get ! 

For more information,  the Family Tree DNA website:

www.familytreedna.com

 

Using all three types of information provided by genealogy DNA testing, people are beginning to truly be able understand our ancestry, not just in last few hundred years, but in the thousands and tens of thousands of years in the past. Where were your ancestors 10,000 years ago? Where did they overwinter the last ice age? Your DNA holds the secrets, and now we begin to unravel your personal mystery.



DNA Results and Ethnic Heritage

One of the most common questions we receive is whether DNA results can indicate ethnic heritage, particularly Native American and African.  Yes, it can, but it doesn’t always.  The answer unfortunately, is not always straightforward.  Let’s start with the Yes answer first.

Yes – In some cases, DNA results can in fact be a very strong indicator of ethnic heritage, particularly in conjunction with additional evidence, such as appearance or family oral or genealogical history.  Some DNA evidence alone is indisputable.

Both the Yline (paternal line test for males only) -

Click here to see an example chart 


- and mitochondrial DNA (maternal line for men and women both) offer the ability, in some cases, to determine the ethnic origin of both Native American, East Asian and Sub Saharan African ancestors.  However, this determination is only relevant to that particular paternal line. 

Going back only 3 generations, you have a total of 8 separate great-grandparents, each of which contributed their genetic heritage to you, and at 4 generations, you have 16 great-great-grandparents -

Click here to see an example chart 


Testing the Yline DNA of your father and the mtdna of your mother, directly or through others who share that particular DNA legacy, provides only the genetic heritage for those 2 lines of your ancestry.  So, yes, if that particular great-grandfather or great-grandmother were of Native, Asian or African ancestry, the Yline and mtdna results may indicate this.  However, if they were mixed race themselves, you may have to test further back in time to discover your ethnic ancestor. 

Click here to see an example chart 


As an example, you can see how we’ve built the DNA inheritance chart on top of the pedigree chart.  Each color represents a different DNA line.

Click here for the final example chart 


Yline testing only tests the y chromosome of the paternal line, and the mitochondrial testing tests only the DNA of the maternal line.  If you cannot obtain descendants of the other lines that contributed to your ethnic heritage, you will not be able to assemble a complete DNA puzzle. 

Some people have turned to a different kind of testing, autosomal, to attempt to fill in those blank spots, with varying results.

Autosomal testing tests portions of the remainder of your DNA.  Both Yline and mitochondrial DNA are important for genealogy because they don’t mix with DNA from the other parent and are therefore passed intact and relatively unchanged from generation to generation, providing a DNA family signature for us to follow through the generations. 

Click here for additional information  

Autosomal DNA testing tests DNA where portions are contributed by both parents, effectively diluting the DNA of each parent by approximately 50% in each generation.  There are two kinds of autosomal DNA tests currently being used by genealogists, Codis markers and biogeographical ancestry (BGA) testing.

An autosomal DNA complication is that while everyone inherits “half” of their genes from each parent, this really isn’t completely true.  Some “groups” of genetic material are inherited together, and you may wind up with more or less genetic material from one of your parents.  In time, certain genetic “traits” will be lost in some descendants, while not in others.  Therefore, you can’t figure actual inheritance percentages by using the 50% rule.  This means that is your father was 50% Native American, you are not necessarily 25%, genetically speaking.

Autosomal Codis markers are the autosomal markers used in paternity testing.  Additionally, they are used by police departments and forensics labs.  The markers employed in these tests are selected specifically to differentiate between people, not to find common markers to place them in ethnic groups.  The results from these tests are only numbers

Click here to see an autosomal results example 

and the recipient is left to their own devices as to how to interpret the results.  These tests are available from numerous sources.  We prefer to interpret these results in conjunction with Yline and mitochondrial DNA tests for a more complete picture.

Autosomal biogeographical ancestry testing tests all of your genetic contributions for specific, proprietary markers that indicate geographical heritage, not just the Yline or mtdna.  This test is currently available from only one source, although the test is resold by several testing companies.  Results from this test are returned as percentages of ethnic heritage. 

Click here to see example of a biogeographical test

Your results are reported within confidence bands, which indicate a range of percentages that might actually be accurate.  The margin of error is often as high as 15%.  Typically, there is no dispute over the majority ancestral type.  However, minority types are apparently much more difficult to discern.

A significant amount of dissention, confusion and speculation exists about the accuracy of autosomal test results as used by genealogists.  Some individuals report results that fit their known or suspected ancestry exactly, and others report exactly the opposite results. 

As with all testing products in this field, improvements are being made constantly and new tests will eventually appear on the market.  All DNA tests, meaning all autosomal tests, based on statistical averages should be viewed as a hint or as a guideline, and not as absolute. 

Click here to see what you get ! 

Let’s talk for a minute about the different types of DNA testing, accuracy and how that affects our interpretation of the results.



DNA Testing and Accuracy

Yline and mitochondrial testing is absolutely accurate and gives you definitive results because neither your Y chromosome (if you’re a male) nor your mitochondrial DNA is mixed with DNA from the other parent.

Your specific results are measured and reported. They are not interpreted, simply reported. You receive your results in a numeric format, for example, at location DYS390 you have 25 repeats.

Click here to see a Yline certificate example 

Mitochondrial DNA results are measured and reported differently, but again, only results are provided.

Click here to see a mitochondrial DNA certificate example 

Autosomal testing is less accurate for genealogy (although CODIS tests are very accurate for paternity testing), because the DNA is diluted with each generation. Additional issues surround the lack and quality of data bases used as a basis of comparison.



Statistics

Some DNA genealogy testing delivers actual results and other testing results are percentages that represent statistical likelihood. Yline, mtdna and autosomal codis test deliver actual results.

Autosomal BGA testing delivers a statistical prediction. This is not a criticism, but is simply the nature of this type of testing.

Remembering that in the year 2000, we had no testing of any type for genealogy, it is in fact remarkable that we have a variety available today.

Because the very word statistics means inference or prediction using mathematical modeling, it also means that there is a margin of error.

To illustrate this for yourself, take out a coin. Everyone knows that you have a 50-50 chance of getting head or tails. However, if you flip a coin 10 times, it is unlikely that you will get exactly 5 heads and 5 tails. However, if you flip the coin enough times, the average of all of the tosses will be an equal amount of heads and tails. This illustrates the difference between actuality and statistics. My test flip totaled 4 tails and 6 heads, and 5 of those heads flips were all in a row, which is statistically unlikely, but was clearly the reality of the experiment.

Extrapolating this example, you can see how, on the average, you get 50% of your genes from each parent, but in actuality, you may not.

This explains why there is a statistical margin of error inherent in autosomal biogeographical testing. The testing company uses statistical prediction methods to generate your results.

This is not the case with Yline or mitochondrial tests, as the results that are returned to you are the raw results, and if you have results indicating Native or African origins, there is little room for speculation. The question then turns from if to when and where.

Testing for Jewish Ancestry

Jewish ancestry is particularly more difficult to discern with testing. Jewishness is identified by both a religion and a culture that arose in the Middle East in relatively modern times, about 2000 years ago, as compared with African Ancestry which reaches back tens of thousands of years, and Native ancestry which also reaches back into Asia millennia ago. Jewish lines have had less time to develop mutations which definitively identify a descendant as one of their “group”.

Another way of putting this is that those of Jewish heritage are also genetic cousins to those who lived in the same area during the same time who were not Jewish, so differentiating them using only DNA is difficult, but not always impossible.

One notable exception is the Cohanim male marker which is easily identifiable through Yline DNA testing. The presence of the Cohanim marker without supporting evidence of a Jewish heritage is not conclusive.

Identifying Jewish heritage using DNA is often a handled on an individual basis and is often more suggestive than definitive.



DNA Tests and Planning

We recommend that you complete a test plan for your particular DNA testing goals before ordering tests. The plan is designed to make sure you order the tests that will actually answer your questions. This helps you avoid purchasing the wrong tests which are both disappointing and expensive.

Order Test Plan

More interesting information about this topic is available at:


www.familytreedna.com

 

National Geographic site project:
www.nationalgeographic.com/genographic

 
 home about services contact online store